Key Character Sorter

Key Fanworks
#41

This is really intresting, I would do this but I don’t remember half of the AB girls and I never played Tomoyo After and Kud Wafter so I cant really make a pick. I’m also in the middle of Kanon lol, but its really intresting, ill give it a go after I finish kanon and tomoyo after. Also you should try making one for best ingame mascots against Pani/Gil/Potato/Chibimosu/Botan ect ect.

1 Like
#42

I don’t know if it’s only me or if someone else has this problem, the sorter asked me only one question about Ui yet she was better than some characters that I chose multiple times :masdum:

anyways, redid it for the sake of Haruko <3

1 Kotori Kanbe

2 Yuri Nakamura

3 Shizuru Nakatsu

4 Terra Route Kagari

5 Lucia Konohana

6 Moon Route Kagari

7 Mio Nishizono

8 Yumemi Hoshino

9 Haruko Kamio

10 Nagisa Furukawa

11 Rin Natsume

12 Misuzu Kamio

13 Komari Kamikita

13 Chihaya Ohtori

15 Haruka Saigusa

15 Akane Senri

17 Kotomi Ichinose

17 Kanade Tachibana

19 Nayuki Minase

19 Yuiko Kurugaya

21 Minagi Tohno

21 Nao Tomori

21 Misa Kurobane

note: I like moon kagari more o.o

#43

That’s not really a problem, that’s just how merge sort works. Conceptually, it works as followed (quoted from Wikipedia):

  1. Divide the unsorted list into n sublists, each containing 1 element (a list of 1 element is considered sorted).
  2. Repeatedly merge sublists to produce new sorted sublists until there is only 1 sublist remaining. This will be the sorted list.

In merging, it can now happen, that one list is worked through earlier, e.g.:
List 1: [1, 2, 3, 4]
List 2: [5, 6, 7, 8]
Compare 1 with 5, 1 gets added
Sorted List: [1]
Compare 2 with 5, 2 gets added
Sorted List:[1, 2]
Compare 3 with 5, 3 gets added
Sorted List: [1, 2, 3]
Compare 4 with 5, 4 gets added
Sorted List: [1, 2, 3, 4]
List 1 is empty, add all other elements from List 2
Sorted List: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8]

In this example 6, 7 and 8 were never asked about. Something similar probably happened while you were sorting.

1 Like
#44

Yeah after trying this thing again with the added characters, I don’t think I can answer this correctly anymore… Kotori got randomly pitted against a kud wafter character and I had no choice to pick “no opinion” (because I’m not gonna give judgement to a character I haven’t experienced yet), and she was pushed down to the middle… Which is simply unfair :stuck_out_tongue:

#45

That’s weird. Does clicking “no opinion” means that the two characters are considered equal? D: (I just really borrowed the code from a blog that freely offered it, and I only know enough HTML to do small editing here and there, so I’m not sure how it really works)

#46

From the several times I’ve tried this, I love both option leads to harems (several characters in one position) while no opinion seems to end up with both characters being pushed down the list.

@Pepe If you have a known character vs an unknown one, just choose the known one and let all the unknown characters occupy the bottom of the list.

#47

It seems that is what it does, yes. In that case “no opinion” may mean the same as “I like both” when in fact it just means it should skip the rating between the two.

Now that’s just kinda unfair :stuck_out_tongue: Because I have characters I actively dislike who actually deserve the bottom spot.

But now that you mention it I could just cut off the bottom spot, yeah

1 Like
#48

I decided to redo the sorter again, especially since Haruko as well as the other Angel Beats! characters were added. I was sort of impressed with this one than my last post, but since my avatar is already Nagisa, I figured I wanted to be fair and to make my decisions carefully.

Here are my results:

  1. Nagisa Furukawa
  2. Ushio
  3. Tomo Mishima
  4. Yumemi Hoshino
  5. Moon Route Kagari
  6. Kotomi Ichinose
  7. Yukine Miyazawa
  8. Terra Route Kagari
  9. Ayu Tsukimiya
  10. Misuzu Kamio
  11. Shiori Misaka
  12. Yuiko Kurugaya
  13. Mio Nishizono
  14. Komari Kamikita
  15. Sayuri Kurata
  16. Sanae Furukawa
  17. Masami Iwasawa
  18. Haruko Kamio
  19. Kotori Kanbe
  20. Akane Senri
  21. Shizuru Nakatsu
  22. Kudryavka Noumi
  23. Rin Natsume
  24. Fuuko Ibuki
  25. Nao Tomori
  26. Yui
  27. Mai Kawasumi
  28. Lucia Konohana
  29. Tomoyo Sakagami
  30. Kyou Fujibayashi
  31. Minagi Tohno
  32. Kannabi no Mikoto
  33. Hisako
  34. Ryou Fujibayashi
  35. Haruka Saigusa
  36. Kanade Tachibana
  37. Nayuki Minase
  38. Chihaya Ohtori
  39. Yuri Nakamura
  40. Mei Sunohara
  41. Uraha
  42. Yusa Nishimori
  43. Shiina
  44. Kano Kirishima
  45. Kanako
  46. Yusa
  47. Miyuki Irie
  48. Misae Sagara
  49. Shiori Sekine
  50. Makoto Sawatari
  51. Saya Tokido
  52. Kanata Futaki
  53. Ui Arizuki
  54. Ayumi Otosaka
  55. Sasami Sasasegawa
  56. Misa Kurobane
  57. Yuuki Himuro
  58. Shiina Arizuki

I had a hard time deciding the rankings of each character because there are some characters as I mentioned in a earlier post without a doubt was very difficult for me. I’m sure those that have used this sorter would understand as well.

#49

A couple of weeks ago my list looked like this.

98Hflgw.png676×779 29.6 KB

This time it came out like this.

KgH2EOJ.png995×921 657 KB

At least my top 10 is pretty consistent. Only got some rearrangements and Kanade and Lucia got replaced by Misuzu and Irie. I have to say that having 2 entries for Kagari is just a pain in the ass. If they were a single entry, Iwasawa would be in that last slot.

Edit: Feb 2019
Finally worked my way through a whole round of this after the update. It’s really hard when I’ve interacted with only 3/10 series in the last two years.

Untitled
Untitled.png1000×647 534 KB

#50

Rank - Character

  1. Komari Kamikita
  2. Kotori Kanbe
  3. Tomoyo Sakagami
  4. Shizuru Nakatsu
  5. Shiori Sekine
  6. Yumemi Hoshino
  7. Shiina
  8. Sanae Furukawa
  9. Akane Senri
  10. Lucia Konohana

Top 3 is pretty accurate! Sekine on top 5 is amusing lol.
@BlackHayate02 so you’ve added Haruko and Sanae; Don’t leave aunt Akiko and Touka out~ :stuck_out_tongue:

#51

Well, as much as I like Akiko and Touka, Haruko and Sanae were added with the idea that Haruko starred the Air route while Sanae had a “mini-route” in After Story. ^^;

#52

ss (2016-07-28 at 09.26.06).jpg169×869 56.7 KB

ss (2016-07-28 at 09.26.40).jpg168×770 48.1 KB

I’m surprised Haru-chin rose to the top while Chihaya managed to be with the KudWaf cast (whom I don’t know about sadly :x )

#53

wel…this is mine it is pretty accurate, it was a nice test :V

Sin título-1.jpg2666×580 1.04 MB

1 Like
#54

This ranking is objectively perfect.
I used an older version and frankly, I think that’s for the best.

Key Heroine ranking Naoki-Saten 07-16.jpg2000×802 377 KB

I don’t know how the two Kagaris got so far apart.

I got your back, comrade. The Mio master race shall reign supreme one day. Shame on the traitors!

3 Likes
#55

Decided to redo the list again, since the sorter has been updated and here are my results:

  1. Kotomi Ichinose
  2. Nagisa Furukawa
  3. Shizuru Nakatsu
  4. Komari Kamikita
  5. Yumemi Hoshino
  6. Misuzu Kamio
  7. Moon Route Kagari
  8. Haruka Saigusa
  9. Rin Natsume
  10. Yukine Miyazawa
  11. Haruko Kamio
  12. Sanae Furukawa
  13. Shiori Misaka
  14. Sayuri Kurata
  15. Kotori Kanbe
  16. Mio Nishizono
  17. Chihaya Ohtori
  18. Misae Sagara
  19. Saya Tokido
  20. Nayuki Minase
  21. Tomoyo Sakagami
  22. Ryou Fujibayashi
  23. Yukio Kurugaya
  24. Mai Kawasumi
  25. Kudryavka Noumi
  26. Kanade Tachibana
  27. Mei Sunohara
  28. Sasami Sasasegawa
  29. Yuri Nakamura
  30. Kanata Futaki
  31. Masami Iwasawa
  32. Minagi Tohno
  33. Akane Senri
  34. Ayu Tsukimiya
  35. Miyuki Irie
  36. Kyou Fujibayashi
  37. Shiina
  38. Uraha
  39. Terra Route Kagari
  40. Ushio
  41. Yui
  42. Fuko Ibuki
  43. Nao Tomori
  44. Makoto Sawatari
  45. Kannabi no Mikoto
  46. Lucia Konohana
  47. Shiina Arizuki
  48. Ui Arizuki
  49. Tomo Mishima
  50. Hisako
  51. Misa Kurobane
  52. Shiori Sekine
  53. Kano Kirishima
  54. Kanako
  55. Yuuki Himuro
  56. Yusa
  57. Yusa Nishimori
  58. Ayumi Otosaka

Not gonna lie, this list was very hard to make and it took me multiple tries, either because I accidentally clicked too fast, or some characters were ranked lower than I wanted them to be. Granted, the latter isn’t that big of a deal at the end of the day, but still.

3 Likes
#56

The top six are pretty accurate objectively. (Totally didn’t just steal a joke.)

key heroine ranking.jpg2491×775 555 KB

nayuki-wins.png468×576 415 KB

That was pretty fun. Tons of battles. Some choices were pretty tough to make, though I feel like the list becomes less and less accurate toward the end, where the most questions were actually asked.

Here’s the resulting list again, in text form.

  1. Nayuki Minase
  2. Tomoyo Sakagami
  3. Ryou Fujibayashi
  4. Shizuru Nakatsu
  5. Moon Route Kagari
  6. Nao Tomori
  7. Minagi Tohno
  8. Miyuki Irie
  9. Ayu Tsukimiya
  10. Ushio
  11. Yumemi Hoshino
  12. Ayumi Otosaka
  13. Misuzu Kamio
  14. Sasami Sasasegawa
  15. Kudryavka Noumi
  16. Yuiko Kurugaya
  17. Akane Senri
  18. Kotori Kanbe
  19. Kanade Tachibana
  20. Masami Iwasawa
  21. Shiina
  22. Sayuri Kurata
  23. Fuuko Ibuki
  24. Mei Sunohara
  25. Tomo Mishima
  26. Komari Kamikita
  27. Kotomi Ichinose
  28. Lucia Konohana
  29. Terra Route Kagari
  30. Shiori Sekine
  31. Yukine Miyazawa
  32. Yuri Nakamura
  33. Rin Natsume
  34. Misa Kurobane
  35. Yusa Nishimori
  36. Shiori Misaka
  37. Nagisa Furukawa
  38. Kyou Fujibayashi
  39. Haruka Saigusa
  40. Kanako
  41. Kanata Futaki
  42. Yui
  43. Hisako
  44. Mai Kawasumi
  45. Mio Nishizono
  46. Saya Tokido
  47. Yuuki Himuro
  48. Shiina Arizuki
  49. Ui Arizuki
  50. Chihaya Ohtori
  51. Sanae Furukawa
  52. Misae Sagara
  53. Yusa
  54. Uraha
  55. Kannabi no Mikoto
  56. Haruko Kamio
  57. Makoto Sawatari
  58. Kano Kirishima
1 Like
#57

untitled.png2250×922 1.29 MB

The Angel Beats girls push a few other characters further down the rankings. Nice to see them on the list.

#58

Praise Yusa!

Also great to see that many people recognise the superiority of Moon Kagari > Terra Kagari. You’re doing me proud.

Rewrite - Kagari Character Discussion
#59

Moon Kagari is of course better than Terra Kagari but… Where is best girl Creamy Kagarin?!
(Also, Michiru from Air is missing, Kaori (Amano, too?) from Kanon and Tomoko Shimako and Inoue from Rewrite)

1 Like
#60

The argument is that none of them are heroines since they don’t have their own routes