Have you seen the PV for the next ep? Interesting.
I havenât. Where can I find it?
Episode 10 preview:
1 Like
Okay, Iâm 100% convinced the cat isnât on our side now.
Since when has a cute mascot in an Uchikoshi game been âon our sideâ? 
If we take everything heâs told Yuuta to be the truth at face value, none of his actions match up. What was it, millions, billions of repetitions? If thatâs true then surely after all that he must have a good idea of how to manipulate Yuuta. Heâd know that telling him what to do wouldnât be effective, so heâd try a different angle to get him to do what he wanted. If he knew exactly what actions caused what results, then why doesnât he explain his grand plan to Yuuta, so that he can follow it through successfully and save the world? They both supposedly have the same goal; why is he keeping critical information from Yuuta? And why is it that he complains about Yuuta changing the future, sometimes intervenes and stops him from changing the future, but other times he wonât do anything about it and simply complain later? It doesnât make sense!
Unless manipulating Yuuta to ensure the successful extinction of mankind was his goal all along. Then his actions begin to make sense.
First, itâs not clear if he wants to manipulate Yuuta or not. So far it looks like he wants to give Yuuta freedom to act when possible. Second, this may be the angle to get Yuuta to âdo what he wanted.â We donât know what the cat wants, so we canât say this isnât the way to do it. Third, saving the world isnât the only goal. To me, it looks like Yuuta needs to be the one to do everything by his own will. Maybe weâll find out why in future.
I just assumed the ones he stopped were big mess up moments from previous loops, and the uncontested moments brought good or unknown outcomes.
That doesnât make sense⊠If that was the case, itâd have ended the first time Earth was destroyed.
Well now.
Iâve been waiting for this since they randomly dropped in the fact that they have a mech.
Iâve kinda lost all hope Punchline will turn into a more serious, somewhat down to Earth story by now.
⊠Have uchikoshi stories ever been âdown to earthâ?
1 Like
Well, yes. Sure we have to suspend our disbelief to a certain degree like any story expects us too, but his stories are usually sober, well-constructed and serious in overall tone. Iâm not sure we are on the same page on what down to Earth means in this case.
For example, Punchline 11 felt just kinda dumb to me. The characters team up against the US army in extremely absurd ways, Ito manages to pilot the mech flawlessly just because itâs the same U.I. as her game, armed professional soldiers just decide to up and leave after being beaten up by a girl in a costume (who didnât even Uberfy), every single attempt at drama just fell flat for me amidst what seems to be a very happy-go-lucky episode where anything is possible.
So yeah, perhaps my problem is that Punchline doesnât take itself seriously. And when it does, it just doesnât mesh well with all the crazyness for me to feel even a bit emotionally invested in it.
Sadly, the 180Âș I was hoping for is not going to happen, it seems.
Yeah I think we do have different ideas on what down to Earth means, haha. I thought it always meant something more rooted in reality
Down to earth, in my books, is used as a way to describe someone that is truthful and realistic. I donât think it really works when describing a story though⊠It sounds weird when used like that. Itâs more of a person or opinion descriptor.
I think âgrounded in realityâ would be the better term to use.
But thatâs what Iâm saying. If you compare Punchline to Ever17 or the Zero Escape series, those are much more grounded in reality and the characters react much more realistically to whatever happens in the story. Sure, the sci-fi can go pretty far, but itâs just a matter of suspending your disbelief (not to mention how the scientific topics used for such stories are usually researched and respected).
So yeah, Zero Escape is something much more rooted in reality than Punchline, for an example. My problem with Punchline is that it never quite commits. When you think the story will go for a more serious approach, the characters just start goofing off again and some crazy stuff (like a mecha battle) happens. Now, this is something that CAN work, but for me Punchline is just never on right note. I thought this would happen after episode 9, but not quite so. Episode 10 was meh and too melodramatic for me, and episode 11 was just too goofy (yeah, 5 girls and a ghost managing to hold off two armies at once for more than 5 minutes is just too goofy).
Oh okay, I think I get what youâre saying now, yeah. Hmmmm Punchline does seem like the odd one out in that case
Well, I just watched the last episode of Punchline andâŠit was rather dumb. At least for me.
The series was just a huge letdown for me. In the begginning, it was funny, but then it began to hint it was not what it seemed and I was pumped. But it never quite commited, itâs gaudy and absurd style remained the same, and whatever seriousness or drama it tried to pull off never worked for me, since it was either too rushed or too melodramatic. Coupled with the persistent fanservice and overall goofiness sometimes right after the serious parts, it just never went past the line of âthis COULD be kinda cool if worked properlyâ. Some twists just felt like they came out of nowhere and others were painfully obvious.
The last two episodes specifically were just dumb. 5 girls and a ghost taking up an army of superhumans AND the US army at the same time and winning almost flawlessly? Come on. Not to mention the extremely corny drama going on with the three main characters. The last scene between them actually made me laugh, and Iâm pretty sure that was not the point.
Unfortunately, this has been a huge letdown for me. Even with Nakazawa at the helm, I donât see how the game version could possibly be any better. Sure, if you turn your brain off it can be funâŠbut the problem is Punchline quite clearly wants you not to as it goes on, and it just results in a pretty big mess. And thatâs a shame, because there is indeed some potential lurking in the shadows here.
1 Like
Yeah, if they kept going with the style of the scene where Yuta and Narugino have their talk, or when Yuta has to write U-turn in the book, itâd have been great.
Still, Iâm looking forward to what the VN has to offer. The anime was clearly a ânow read the VN!â story.
Mmmm⊠I enjoyed the series for the most part, but it just kinda ended abruptly, I felt. Like it was going in a good direction but never quite went as far as I wouldâve hoped.
They are saving the good stuff. The anime was like an advertisement, I guess.
