RIN1 TIME
I’m experimenting with ‘details’ boxes this time and since we’re attempting to protect hose of us who haven’t already finished Rin1 I think this is the perfect time to see how they work. I’m going to be dividing up my thoughts/analysis of this route into some primary sections, to make it all a bit easier to sort through/read. Since there are no ‘days’ in the character routes i figure it makes sense to just do each as one big post and clarify things as we move through the bookclub. With that said, let’s head right to the obvious starting point, the present!
The Present: Rin as a Character
This is Rin’s route, and as i’ve covered she’s the ‘main heroine’ of our novel, so i’ll expect there to be a heavy amount of foreshadowing in this route in particular. Also, since we’re no longer in the Common route i expect almost every scene to relate explicitly to Rin or Rin’s relationship(s) with Riki. With that out of the way, we get introduced to our first conflict:
This gosh darned letter. Honestly it was the most confusing part of the entire route for me, the introduction of apparent fan favourite Mutsume Suginami, a quiet girl who’s really into Riki who hasn’t had the courage to approach him. She only confesses to Riki at the machinations of her friends who deliver this letter to Riki’s locker. Soon after Riki talks to his friends about what he should do, Rin confesses to him and they begin their long-lasting relationship.
So, why on Earth does the Rin route start with the confession of an entirely different character? Because the friend’s pushing of Riki and Suganimi mirrors Kyousuke’s manipulation of Rin and Riki to get their relationship to blossom. By situating them as both catcher and pitcher forcing them to ‘rely’ on one another, by delivering their tasks which they can only accomplish if they work together, by generally pushing both of them to face challenges and overcome obstacles he is encouraging them to accept their feelings for one another and to confront their dark past but we’ll get to that later and to start a relationship.
The relationship unfolds slowly, like, iceberg slowly. Even the Titanic would have time to get out of the way. The preparation for the visit of the advisory board was particularly amusing, watching Rin having absolutely no idea how to deal with authority other than by fighting it, and Riki supporting her mostly quietly while Kyousuke coached her. A certain scene later on seemed to represent their relationship in the context of the wider ‘Little Busters attitude’ particularly well. Riki and Rin are alone in Riki’s living space and they have an adorable back and forth on how they can ‘deepen their relationship.’ I discussed this fairly thoroughly in my post on Riki, but he is no regular harem protagonist. In most novels this would be the H-scene, the big payoff, the moment that the reader’s fantasies come to life, but this hardly seems to cross his mind as an option. Instead, he decides they should go out on the town. I think this is pretty telling of Riki, our protagonist, in terms of how uncomfortable he is with the idea of progressing this relationship, and of change. Rin herself is pretty bad at people and I believe only took the initiative of proposing a romantic relationship because of Suginami’s interest, she only said anything because a threat prompted her to.
BUT (and this is a big but) she did ask Riki out, she did go through with the Secret of the World task with some light prodding from Riki (failing to do so gets you a bad end) and she does consider moving to a completely separate school when she gets the chance to. She has shown significant growth as a result of the quest to find the Secret, the baseball pitching, Riki’s relationship deepening, and even her rival with Sasami. Riki connects her personal growth all the way back to the first delivery of Lennon’s letter, something that he used to be excited about but now seems to loathe.
Talk about a correlation=causation fallacy!
The point is, Rin has shown that she can change and Riki doesn’t like it. I do find it very interesting that Rin considers moving away from Riki so soon after starting going out, but I get the feeling that if Rin were to head over to the school then Riki would have gone with her. Kyousuke explains that she’s been picked in order to introduce positive influences into the other school after a traffic incident occurred that killed everyone of the students involved except for two. The incident left an impression on the school that can only be fixed by people like Rin with their excitable demeanours and smiling faces.
Speaking of which, I neglected to mention that there is another symbolic meaning we can take from Rin’s name. Bells can also be used to symbolise happiness in Japanese society, I think that it is very fitting that she would be the one to bring ‘happiness’ to the other school, especially as the spiral of happiness is a theme of this novel. Anyhow, let’s move onto more depressing matters in the past!
The Past: Narcolepsy and other Traumatic Incidents
So if you’re a crazy person like me you would have noticed that rather than the novel emphasizing the number of students killed in the accident it decided to tell us how many survived the incident. Since the most prominent placement of ‘the two’ in this novel so far is Rin and Riki I have to assume it’s them, especially following my analysis of Riki’s narcolepsy, which was mot likely caused by Brain Trauma which in term was most likely caused by either a tragic accident or someone deliberately giving him the injury. Of the options i selected a motor vehicle as the most likely suspect. I’m fairly certain that the incident mentioned by Kyousuke (who is very knowledgeable about the whole thing despite it only being mentioned that day to him by Rin) involved Rin and Riki. I’m unsure whether Rin and Riki were shuffled over to this school after being in that incident or if we’re dealing with some shuffling of details due to Riki’s state of mind. If we are dealing with a comatose state with some lucidity then his mind is most likely shuffling his memories and blending them with fantasy in order to process whatever happened to him.
The biggest point of confusion for me is still when exactly the brain trauma occurred. Typically amnesia only affects events either before or after the instigation. There seem to be memories missing from all different parts of his life, so I have to assume it occurred right after the big baseball game. Maybe it was a rainy day and Rin pitched poorly and clocked Riki in the head? Or perhaps my van-crash theory still holds some weight? But then why is there also a traffic accident? And what exactly happened to Riki’s parents? I think that regardless of the overarching plot Riki is messing up the chronology of events and is being very selective about what he remembers. He’s certainly using what he remembers of the loved ones around him and how they coped with their problems as a crutch to cope with his own incident. Which brings me to…
The Future: Riki's Fear
The future. We are spoken to directly by some unknown entity at the end of the route and hoo boy this was fun. I was a little spooked to be honest, but I was too very happily screenshotting every single line to be anything but excited as I progressed through the final moments of Rin1. The voice says exactly this to Riki:
“Congratulations on making it this far.
But nothing has started yet.
Things will not go so easily.
That path which you didn’t take…
Try to accept it next time.”
On a surface level this seems to be fourth-wall breaking, the voice is urging the player to check out the other routes. On this level it would be cute but due to the ominous presentation it simply can’t be that simple. On the next level i and a few other theorists have thought it might refer to a choice that we don’t have access to in Rin1, a choice that will only become available to us after completing all of the heroine’s routes and coming back for Rin2. This choice has to be to allow Rin to leave to the other school. This in itself is all well and good but i think we can break down the meaning of this choice into a bit more detail.
Even after seeing the value of progressing his relationship with Rin, Riki despises change. He just can’t handle it. He is so incredibly fixated on the idea of the happy times continuing forever, it’s been repeated continuously throughout the common route and is setting up what i believe to be the central conflict of our main character:
Resistance to change
Why does this matter? Well, he’s in control of all of this. This entire setup is one big way of Riki attempting to face the pain he’s in outside of this world’ when he waked up. In fact, I would even say that he ‘fears’ change
Darkness is representative of the passage of time, as indicated by multiple instances in this route when Riki and Rin are out on the town and passage of time is indicated by a black screen with a series of dots in the text box, the same thing is seen in this end sequence here. Riki fears the darkness because of the implication, he doesn’t just ‘fear darkness’ (because that’s stupid you fear what’s in the darkness) rather he fears waking up from this dream he’s in, this ‘sanctuary’ he’s discovered where he can avoid dealing with his trauma and just be safe. The choice that the voice is referring to isn’t just to let Rin go to the other school but is symbolic of allowing change into his life, and to progress time. He will continue to repeat this period of time until he can learn to accept that he can’t stay locked up in his own mind forever and that he will have to take responsibility and act with the power of his friend’s memories behind him.
Especially Kyousuke’s.
Kyousuke in this coma-scenario is basically Riki’s subconscious will to live. Riki seems to be somewhat aware of this, realizing at the last moment that Kyousuke is responsible for the letter, knowing about the visit to the school, the traffic accident, everything. Kyousuke may be my favourite character simply due to the reach he seems to have in Riki’s universe. At least in this route the entire two week period has been engineered with the goal of pushing Riki and Rin to the other school, so that they can confront their past demons. How do I know Riki knows? Well:
Oh yes, Riki knows. He just won’t consciously acknowledge that Kyousuke could be behind the letter due to his idolisation of the man. Anyway, Kyousuke is Riki’s will to escape from the stagnant state and accept change, and Rin is the light at the end of the tunnel or the bell ringing through the darkness.
Ching
The Bonus: Rereading Rin1
Bonus Round! So i was going to check out some of the other choice options and was holdin ‘c’ like a madman, and was pleasantly surprised to uncover a number of scenes which only occur after having completed Rin1 once before. It’s fairly straightforward, generally Rin is much more competent at behaving properly, even trumping Kyousuke a few times, and she earns herself a crazy new success sound that sounds like something out of a 90s gameshow.
Of course, I would be remiss if I were not to mention Kengo’s uniform.
Continuity confirmed!
The situation has clearly ‘evolved’ from last time, to the point that Kyousuke ‘remembers’ the fact that the visitors mentioned Kengo’s lack of uniform from last time and as such told him to shape up this time. Looking good kengo I still don’t think we’re dealing with a supernatural timeloop or simulation in the story, that would be a little too far out of what i expect from the novel, but i think this is more likely a result of Riki’s subconscious understanding the people around him better, remembering the way that they changed as he got to know them better. I believe that by the time we get to Refrain almost all of the characters will have changed such that we can see a significant difference in the way the common route unfolds.
Oh my goodness did you actually read all that? Thanks! Well then, let’s lay down some Key Topics:
First, obvious one, what do you think of the coma theory? Do you agree? Disagree? Let me know what you think!
Second, how do you feel about the novel’s concept of a sanctuary? Are they a positive or a negative thing? Does it depend on the person or circumstance?
Thirdly I’d like to hear your thoughts on Rin and her place in the story. Do you think she’s fun? Annoying? Adorable? Crazy? What would change your mind?
And Fourthly, (spoilers for Rin1 in case you’re scrolling through): I didn’t talk about this (but I have my theories) who do you think the mysterious ‘voice’ is at the end of the route? Kyousuke? Rin? Riki? …Suginami? Does it matter?
Now if you’ll excuse me I’m going to go see if i can’t catch a little ‘free-dom time’ over with Mio. I hear there might be (minor spoilers?) some birds?